Posts Tagged ‘price fixing’

Antitrust Division Indicts Japanese National in Yet Another LCD Monitor Case

Thursday, April 2nd, 2009

keiretsu.png

The DOJ got an indictment this week against a Hitachi executive, in the government’s ongoing prosecution of alleged price-fixing in the LCD monitor industry.

We first blogged on this back on November 13th, when Sharp, LG Display and Chunghwa all pled guilty to price fixing, agreeing to pay $585 million in fines. Since then, Chungwha executives also pled guilty during February.

After the Chungwha executive pleas, Hitachi itself agreed in March to plead guilty and pay $31 million in fines.

Breaking from the pattern, however, rather than a Hitachi executive subsequently pleading guilty, the feds went ahead and indicted him.

According to a DOJ press release, Tuesday’s indictment charges a Japanese national, Sakae Someya, who was an executive at Hitachi Displays Ltd. Mr. Someya is accused of taking part in a larger global conspiracy to fix the prices of LCD panels sold to Dell.

Mr. Someya is accused of agreeing to charge set prices for the screens, sharing sales information to ensure everyone was complying with the agreed prices, and trying to keep the arrangement secret. These are Sherman Act charges, with a max of 10 years in prison plus a max fine of the greater of $1 million, double the gain, or double the loss to victims.

We wonder how much of the allegedly criminal conduct is simply normal business practice in Japanese culture. After all, the keiretsu distribution system used by Japanese industry looks very much like price fixing to Western eyes.

It certainly looks to us as though the DOJ’s Antitrust Division is busting through decades of resistance to offshore enforcement of U.S. antitrust rules. Whether it is proper to impose U.S. laws on a very foreign culture… that’s another question entirely. What do you think?

Antitrust Division Cuts Flat-Screen Prices, Just in Time for the Holidays

Thursday, November 13th, 2008

Antitrust Division gets guilty pleas in TV price-fixing conspiracy

Three major flat-screen TV and monitor manufacturers have pled guilty to price fixing, in a case brought by the DOJ’s Antitrust Division.

Sharp, LG Display and Chunghwa will pay $585 million in fines, pursuant to their plea. The DOJ alleged that, as a result of the price-fixing conspiracies, consumers paid inflated prices for products with LCD screens. Affected products ranged from flat-screen TVs to computer monitors, laptops, iPods and cell phones.

Division chief Thomas O. Barnett stated that these were international conspiracies that “affected millions of American consumers who use computers, cell phones and numerous other household electronics every day.” Without calculating how much extra the consumers wound up paying, he predicted that this plea would now result in lower prices.

The Wall Street Journal reports that the world’s largest LCD maker, Samsung, had cooperated with the Antitrust Division and was not named in the plea announcement. AAG Barnett declined to comment on whether Samsung had received legal immunity. Federal law provides that the first company to give evidence of a criminal conspiracy can receive immunity. When the investigation first became public in 2006, Samsung stated that it had “pledged its full and continuing cooperation” with law enforcement.